Article · Political lens · Economic lens

The tragedy that did not happen

For decades it was believed that the commons were doomed to ruin. Elinor Ostrom went to look, and found communities able to govern them.

Empty editorial team · · 4 minutes

In 1968 the ecologist Garrett Hardin published an article that would become a classic: The Tragedy of the Commons. He imagined a pasture open to all. Each herder, Hardin reasoned, has an interest in adding one more animal, because the gain is his and the damage is shared by everyone. So, one after another, they all add animals, until the pasture is destroyed. The conclusion seemed inevitable: either the state takes control, or the land is privatised.

Going to look

Elinor Ostrom, an American political scientist, did something simple and rare: she went to look. She studied Alpine pastures in Switzerland, irrigation systems in Nepal and the Philippines, fisheries, forests. In many cases she found communities that had managed shared resources for centuries without destroying them, and without handing them over to the state or the market.

In 1990 she gathered this research in Governing the Commons. In 2009 she received the Nobel Prize in Economics, the first woman ever to do so.

What they had in common

The communities that succeeded shared a few things: clear boundaries, rules suited to the place, the chance for those who use the resource to help decide the rules, forms of mutual monitoring, graduated sanctions, simple ways to resolve conflicts. Nothing heroic. Just people who talked to each other, watched each other and trusted each other enough to keep an agreement.

Hardin’s mistake

Hardin’s mistake was not in the calculation but in the premise: he imagined isolated herders who neither communicate nor know each other. Ostrom showed that real people are not like that. They are interwoven, and when they can recognise it, they find ways to care together for what they all depend on.

In many cases the tragedy did not happen. It came only where the web of relationships had been broken.

What is a common good in the place where you live, one that nobody owns and everybody depends on? Who looks after it?

Sources: G. Hardin, "The Tragedy of the Commons", Science, 1968; E. Ostrom, Governing the Commons, Cambridge University Press, 1990.

A letter, every two weeks. Nothing more.

A threshold, an echo, a reflection.

Free. Unsubscribe with one click.